Topic 14 · Four anonymous paper-route feedback cards

Notice, Question, Next test

Cut or use one card per showcase round. Critique the work and its evidence, not the person. Do not write a reviewer name, private detail, score, or personality judgment.

10-minute round: 4 minutes defense, 2 minutes evidence questions, 2 minutes feedback, 2 minutes transfer. The presenter decides whether to Accept, Test, Defer, or Reject feedback after checking evidence and scope.

Round 1 of 4

NOTICE: What visible evidence worked?

QUESTION: What claim, boundary, or source needs clarification?

NEXT TEST: What one bounded check would help?

Presenter: ☐ Accept ☐ Test ☐ Defer ☐ Reject

Round 2 of 4

NOTICE: What visible evidence worked?

QUESTION: What claim, boundary, or source needs clarification?

NEXT TEST: What one bounded check would help?

Presenter: ☐ Accept ☐ Test ☐ Defer ☐ Reject

Round 3 of 4

NOTICE: What visible evidence worked?

QUESTION: What claim, boundary, or source needs clarification?

NEXT TEST: What one bounded check would help?

Presenter: ☐ Accept ☐ Test ☐ Defer ☐ Reject

Round 4 of 4

NOTICE: What visible evidence worked?

QUESTION: What claim, boundary, or source needs clarification?

NEXT TEST: What one bounded check would help?

Presenter: ☐ Accept ☐ Test ☐ Defer ☐ Reject